Haik won’t dismiss Lyons v. Knight; invites appeal
[Editor's Note: This story has been modified to reflect that the defendants had not filed an appeal in the case, only a reconsideration of an earlier ruling, and that there are two suits pending in the case.]
A federal judge has upheld his earlier ruling in a lawsuit brought against a powerful Lafayette oil family by their former interior decorator, yet, according to a source familiar with such federal cases, he took the rare step of urging the defendants to appeal to the Fifth Circuit. U.S. District Court Judge Richard Haik this week ruled against members of the Knight family, who challenged Haik’s ruling last May that let the lawsuit brought against them by Judy Lyons stand.
Lyons originally filed the suit against the Knights and their company in state district court in Lafayette in early 2011. Judge Marilyn Castle sided with the Knights and dismissed the suit, but the 3rd Circuit Court of Appeal reversed Castle’s ruling. While Lyons’ suit was pending before the 3rd Circuit the Knights filed suit against Lyons seeking to recover monetary damages they claimed they suffered. But the Knights didn’t pursue the civil claim against Lyons and the suit expired. Knight counter-sued.
In October of last year, the Knights successfully petitioned the state court to transfer the second suit to federal court because Lyons’ suit brought a RICO claim against the family. Named for the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act, a law enacted in 1970 to help the federal government better prosecute organized crime, a RICO claim can be brought against individuals or corporations that work with law enforcement to bring, as Lyons’ alleges and her criminal acquittal supports, false charges against an individual.
In effect Lyons’ has two civil lawsuits against the Knights — one in state court and the other in federal court.
In his ruling this week, Haik invited the Knight family to take their appeal to a higher authority:
Given this is an issue which involves a controlling question of law as to which there is substantial ground for a difference of opinion and that a ruling as to whether a claim under the RICO Act exists in this matter would materially advance the ultimate determination of this litigation, the Court hereby certifies this issue for appeal to the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, should the parties wish to take such action.
Lyons’ attorney declined comment on this week’s ruling.
For the background on this sordid story, click here.
Subscribe to this comment's feed
- Developing Acadiana ABiz’s annual commercial real estate roundtable discussion comes to life.
- Optimism Reigns Commercial real estate professionals say the best is yet to come.
- Dollars for DocsHow to evaluate pharmaceutical company payments to physicians
- First Quarter EPI 2013In cooperation with LEDA, each quarter ABiz presents the Lafayette Economic Performance Index. The EPI tracks the strength of the local economy by combining multiple data points into a single score that is compared over time.
On the Move: Joey Auer
A seasoned IT specialist and successful businessman, Auer joins Lafayette's Global Data Systems.
Pinot’s Palette opens in South College Shopping Center
Your creative juices will flow, just as the wine flows into your glass.
Developing Acadiana
ABiz’s annual commercial real estate roundtable discussion comes to life.
Renovations complete for University Place Apts.
After years of neglect, University Place Apartments will enter the fall semester a top contender for off-campus housing for UL students thanks to new ownership and a recently completed multi-million dollar renovation.
From ‘Boat to Throat’
According to those who know it best, Louisiana’s famed oyster industry is in a precarious state.
Business Scene
Speaking at ABiz’s second annual State of the Economy event May 9 at the Cajundome Convention Center, LEDA President and CEO Gregg Gothreaux noted Lafayette Parish’s record-breaking retail sales in 2012
ABiz People
Robert Patrick “Pat” Breaux has joined Le Triomphe Golf and Country Club as executive chef.
Legal Matters: The Name Game
Choosing and protecting a trademark is serious business — almost as serious as the business itself.
Toot and Scoot Service Coming to South Lafayette
Acadiana Prescription Shop expands near Lourdes campus.
Along the Waterfront
Le Virage Marina is a 10-acre residential development on Vermilion River offering residents a home away from home cottage-styled campsite, complete with all the amenities of city life and direct access to Vermilion Bay.
Clucks from the Capitol
This year’s regular session was an incubator for Lafayette politics, with some folks emerging hatched and others cracked.
Optimism Reigns
Commercial real estate professionals say the best is yet to come.
First Quarter EPI 2013
In cooperation with LEDA, each quarter ABiz presents the Lafayette Economic Performance Index. The EPI tracks the strength of the local economy by combining multiple data points into a single score that is compared over time.
Dollars for Docs
How to evaluate pharmaceutical company payments to physicians
No new tenants yet at Whole Foods site
Houston-based developer says the center is moving in a “decidedly upscale” direction.
Frank’s Casing Crew going public
Local company hopes to raise $500 million in Initial Public Offering with the Mosing family members retaining 85 percent ownership.
LGMC expanding Hub City residency program
The UMC medical residency program slated to re-emerge under the management of Lafayette General Medical Center will expand the number of Hub City doctors in training by 20, bringing the total number of resident docs in Lafayette to more than 80.
Outlaws becomes The District
Johnston Street saloon and dance hall to become premier live music venue.
Six years later, Teche Ridge turns dirt again
The concept of a traditional neighborhood development has been a tough sell in New Iberia, and a tough road for the nonprofit Southern Mutual Help Association, which after overcoming numerous obstacles over the last six years, seems on the verge of making the long-awaited Teche Ridge a reality.
On air soon: 'Soul of the South'
Channel surfers will soon find a new urban-focused television station, possibly as early as this week, says Delta Media General Manager Chuck Wood. “Soul of the South — Lafayette” could go live on local Channel 32 either tonight or Tuesday.
Weekly unemployment insurance claims drop
The state labor department figures released Friday show the initial claims decreased to 3,306 from the previous week's total of 3,386. For the comparable week a year earlier, there were 4,177 initial claims.
Louisiana economic growth lags nation in 2012
New figures show that Louisiana's economy grew by 1.5 percent in 2012, leaving it ranked 30th among the 50 states.
B.R. company to pay $67K in Labor Department probe
A Baton Rouge-based company has agreed to pay more than $67,000 in back wages and other compensation to 52 masonry workers following a Labor Department probe.
Bullritos adds second location on Johnston Street
Build-your-own burrito franchise comes to Winnwood Shopping Center this fall.
Economic Indicators
- Real Estate Data
- Energy Data
- Taxable Sales
- Unemployment Rate
Read the Flipping Paper!
Click Here for the Entire Print Version ofABiz
Aggreko
Company ID [LON:AGK] Last trade:GBX1,765.04 Trade time:4:44PM GMT+1 Value change:▼25.96 (-1.45%)IberiaBank Corp
Company ID [NASDAQ:IBKC] Last trade:52.50 Trade time:4:00PM EDT Value change:▲0.52 (1.00%)LHC Group
Company ID [NASDAQ:LHCG] Last trade:22.53 Trade time:3:59PM EDT Value change:▲0.28 (1.26%)MidSouth Bancorp
Company ID [AMEX:MSL] Last trade:15.71 Trade time:4:03PM EDT Value change:▲0.03 (0.19%)PetroQuest Energy
Company ID [NYSE:PQ] Last trade:4.64 Trade time:4:03PM EDT Value change:▲0.03 (0.65%)PHI Inc
Company ID [NASDAQ:PHII] Last trade:33.99 Trade time:3:58PM EDT Value change:▲0.50 (1.49%)Superior Energy
Company ID [NYSE:SPN] Last trade:28.13 Trade time:4:03PM EDT Value change:▲0.25 (0.90%)Stone Energy
Company ID [NYSE:SGY] Last trade:23.42 Trade time:4:01PM EDT Value change:▼0.20 (-0.85%)Teche Holding Corp
Company ID [AMEX:TSH] Last trade:42.29 Trade time:4:01PM EDT Value change:▲0.09 (0.21%)Most Read
-
Glenn Stewart convicted
In rendering his ruling, District Judge John Trahan all but called the real estate developer a liar for inconsistencies in his accounts of what prompted him to punch a school teacher unconscious. -
Dana Baker resigns from Festival International
-
Frank’s Casing Crew going public
Frank’s Casing Crew, now doing business as Frank’s International, will make its final appearance on ABiz’s list of the Top 50 Privately Held Companies in Acadiana this year, and once again, it will likely be at the top with more than $1 billion in annual revenues. The 75-year-old company specializing in tubular fabrication and installation services to the oil and gas industry plans to go public this year. -
Landry, Pierre playing the blame game
The defeat, or rather highjacking of House Bill 420 in the final days of this year's Legislative Session, say Reps. Vincent Pierre and Terry Landry, is the result of the propaganda spread by one unidentified local media outlet and an unnamed former state Representative, but nothing to do with the original legislation's lack of checks, balances or details. -
Shelvin loses cool, fails to disclose conflict
City-Parish Council Chairman Brandon Shelvin heaped steady doses of condescending ire on a Blue Cross/Blue Shield of Louisiana executive while failing to reveal his financial ties to a BC/BS rival.
in case you missed it
-
The One Who Got Away
Abbeville native David Primeaux was a popular professor until his death late last year, and while he was successful at camouflaging a dark past, he couldn’t outlive it. -
Fore!
Before District Attorney Mike Harson tees off for a fifth term in office, he should seriously consider what might be coming at him. -
The Day Primeaux Died
Now we know why the former pedophile priest committed suicide late last year, and the story behind it is more riveting than his death. -
Risky Business
Tehmi Chassion’s failure to recuse himself in the school board’s selection of a group health benefits provider raises ‘serious questions’ on whether he violated state ethics law. -
Posthaste VS. DAVID EGAN
He’s a singer. A songwriter. A piano man. A family man. He’s even got his own Wikipedia entry. He’s David Egan. And he knows ancient secrets about the monolithic stones of Stonehenge that he’s not willing to share.