Wednesday, January 26, 2011
The Greater Lafayette Chamber of Commerce probably did more harm to itself than to Sen. Mike Michot with its legislative scorecard. By Walter Pierce
A first-quarter political drought extending from City-Parish Council leadership elections to the commencement of redistricting was admirably filled by the Greater Lafayette Chamber of Commerce, which, stomping around Muscle Beach, kicked sand in the face of not only a longtime member but one of its most ardent supporters both in Lafayette and at the Capitol in Baton Rouge.
When the chamber gave state Sen. Mike Michot an F on the legislative scorecard it released Jan. 12, it may have done more to diminish its influence with the Legislature than it did to burnish its political cred.
The chamber is new to politics and apparently keenly unaware of realpolitik. Its political action committee, Empower PAC, rolled out of the garage last year, pistons misfiring. The PAC equivocated badly leading up to last October’s school board elections, endorsing competing candidates in two of the districts — I had always understood an endorsement to be a means of favoring one candidate over another — and it idled on the shoulder during the very public debate about the school board purchasing the abandoned Super Kmart site for a technical high school.
And then came the scorecard.
“What I’m hearing is that the chamber was just going to flex some muscle and say, ‘Hey, we’re going to be a real organization now and set up a PAC and come up with a scorecard,’” a grinning-and-bearing-it Michot told me last week. “And I really feel like the ultimate impact has been just the opposite — that it’s going to dilute the chamber’s effectiveness and marginalize its muscle at the Capitol.”
I wrote a story about the reaction to the scorecard for the current issue of The Independent’s sister pub ABiz, out in news racks today. I spoke with people involved in economic development in Lafayette and got essentially the same reaction: What was the chamber thinking?
Dr. Paula Carson, an assistant vice president in UL’s business school and chair of the Lafayette Economic Development Authority, among other roles, took Michot’s F as a personal affront. She has worked closely with Michot as the Senate Finance Committee chairman acted on behalf of LEDA, LITE, UL and other entities.
“I can say that no matter what hat I wore, I was professionally and personally hurt for Sen. Michot to be publicly evaluated in a way that I don’t think fairly represented his contribution,” Carson told me.
But clearly the most put off by the scorecard was the man on its business end. Michot considers the F a “slap in the face” and told me he doesn’t plan to renew his chamber membership. And he wasn’t alone in his pique. We learned from sources across the business community in Lafayette that chamber President/CEO Rob Guidry was contacted via phone and email by several people who expressed reactions ranging from outrage to dismay to disappointment.
Unfortunately, I was unable to reach Guidry in time for the ABiz story. (The chamber’s lobbyist, Gifford Briggs, declined comment.) But I did speak to Guidry about the scorecard late last week. He was his usual sanguine self.
“When you get into a political arena like that, it’s the nature of the environment to get push back on some of those scores,” Guidry said.
Especially troubling to many was the fact that Michot’s grade was adversely affected by four votes he missed during the 2010 session — one third of the dozen votes by which the chamber graded members of Acadiana’s Senate delegation. But as Senate Finance chairman, Michot gets pulled away from the Senate floor frequently to deal with myriad matters related to the budget. Missing votes is not uncommon. According to the scorecard, a lawmaker received a Mulligan if his/her absence was “excused,” but the chamber, like an exacting schoolmarm, bestowed excused absences on none of the 21 representatives and senators subject to its report card.
Guidry admits the issue of absences will be revisited: “We are reviewing those criteria as we speak,” he told me.
Michot has been a member of the chamber for more than two decades — he owns a local home health company — and has chaired one of its committees, emceed its banquets and hosted its Leadership Lafayette classes at the Capitol. To say he has been a friend of the chamber is to understate the relationship. More like BFF, which makes many wonder — and speculate over drinks — whether there’s something more to his poor showing on the scorecard.
A prime candidate is the fracas during the 2010 session over the budget flex bills, which would have given the state wider discretion in cutting the budget to save health care and higher ed from shouldering the brunt of cuts. The legislation died in the House, but a Michot-sponsored flex bill sailed through the Senate on a 30-9 vote. Only one chamber of commerce in the state opposed the package. Care to venture a guess?
Fast forward to August of last year, post-session, and the Lake Charles-based Chamber of Southwest Louisiana’s annual Legis-Gator awards banquet. According to a reliable count, 53 state lawmakers including several from Lafayette attended. Michot, not coincidentally, received the group’s “Legis-Gator of the Year” award, cited for exhibiting “innovative leadership through the serious financial challenges affecting the state in 2010.”
At a similar chamber-hosted event a month later at the Crowne Plaza in Lafayette, not a single member of the local legislative delegation showed up. That, as one Lafayette political operative put it, is “the canary in the coal mine.”
The point of a PAC is to achieve a legislative goal — that’s the political action in political action committee — and the Greater Lafayette Chamber of Commerce is certainly right to pursue an agenda it believes is beneficial to its membership. But practicing political retribution, especially against a powerful, term-limited state senator who has one last legislative session to help — or to be indifferent to — the chamber, is counterproductive.
Local 101 class Friday
“Byzantine” is the word members of the nominating committee for the local flood protection authority often use to describe the complicated, multi-layered matrix of qualifications that must be met to fill a vacancy on that board.
In the Pelican State, Benjamin Franklin buys you about $109 worth of stuff.
Brittan Bush joins Liskow & Lewis, Blake David installed as the Third District Member of the Louisiana State Bar Association’s board of governors, and Simien & Miniex announces 2014 scholarship winners.
“In some cases, we’ve found that these parts are nothing more than used junk yard parts. In others, we’ve found them to be foreign knock-off parts of questionable quality.”
The old Daily Advertiser building on Jefferson Street is being rehabbed as the owner prepares to move it back into commerce.
Its fourth leader gone after two years on the job, the facility struggles to balance the tension between its two missions.
Hub City Cycles hits the ground running through small-business center opportunity.
The future of the coastal loss lawsuit could rest in hands of board’s nominating committee.
Leaders from the local tech community ponder the question: What's missing from Acadiana's tech ecosystem?
AT&T’s U-verse heads our way. Here’s what it means for you.
LITE’s virtual environments are changing the way local employees learn how to do their jobs.
Local tech gurus will go the distance to call Lafayette home.
A look at recent hires, promotions and other news from Acadiana's business community.
New Johnston Street eatery catapults to No. 1 spot in nearly 200-location chain.
By identifying companies that match the output of its post-secondary educational institutions, Lafayette is creating opportunities that keep highly trained graduates in the area.
Gideon’s Promise lauds G. Paul Marx’s work to improve the quality of indigent defense and helps train five new public defenders.
What will INNOV8 4.0 look like?
Courtesy Ford is honored; EatLafayette fêtes itself
AG says 50-year-old Terry Francis Savoy sold fraudulent Workers Compensation and Employers Liability insurance policies throughout the state.
The state's jobless rate rose to 5.4 percent in July from 5 percent in June. Louisiana's unemployment rate was 6.4 percent in July 2013.
Oil Center eatery plans drive-thru location on Ambassador Caffery
Royal Dutch Shell has agreed to sell drilling rights in shale formations in Louisiana and Wyoming for $2.1 billion in two transactions.
Local skate shop collaborates with sneaker giant to create the "Crawfish Dunks"
Lafayette-based drilling fluids/frac sand distributor enhances service lines with purchase of Erath company.