The oil industry has historically been a source of great returns for investors.
November 2012

Prices at the pump got you down? Well, as they say, “If you don’t have an oil well, get one.” And if you can’t do that, how about this: “If you don’t have an oil company, buy one of those.”  

Owning an oil company. What a thought. Makes me go all warm and fuzzy inside. Well, you may never actually own an entire oil company, but you sure can own a piece of one. In fact, if you’re a long-term investor, maybe you should. The long-term returns historically offered by oil industry companies have been terrific.  

But wait a moment, let’s think this through — do you want to own a staid and mature exploration and production company, or would you rather invest in the wild west, boom-bust service company side of the business? Or, to put it another way, if I asked you to guess which side of the oil business — the major producers or the service companies — would have made the best investments over the last 25 years, what would you say?  

Well, my first guess was that the service companies probably provided the highest return. After all, it appears to be feast or famine for them. Seems like investors ought to get compensated for that ride. But when I looked closely at the data, I discovered that my guess was wrong. And it wasn’t even close.

chartThe accompanying chart shows the long-term total return growth (a hypothetical $10,000 investment) of two of the largest E&P companies — Exxon and Chevron versus two of the major service companies that support the industry (Schlumberger and Halliburton).    
Wow, no contest. Now that’s not to say that the service companies have been a bad investment. They haven’t been. In fact, they’ve been fine. An equal investment in Halliburton and Schlumberger over the last 22 years would have grown $10,000 to roughly $76,000. But the major production companies have simply been terrific. An equivalent investment in Chevron and Exxon over the same period would have grown that same $10,000 to more than $148,000. That’s a lot of fill-ups at your local station.

Why might this be? My guess is that because the major companies have a highly diversified business portfolio, there is usually at least one aspect of their business doing well at any given time. For example, following the 2010 BP oil spill, while the share price of service companies was crushed as activity in the Gulf shut down, the share prices of the major production companies held up fine. Sure, new drilling activity slowed, but existing production (and cash flow) kept on flowing. The major producers simply have an advantage that the service industry does not. And don’t forget the long-term beneficial effects of the relatively high dividends paid by the large production companies. These dividends really go a long way toward enhancing total return over time.

I’ll be the first to admit that we are looking at past returns. And as everyone knows, past performance does not guarantee future results. So, whether or not this disparity in total investment return of operators versus service contractors continues is anybody’s guess. But this much seems clear — it’s simply all good. So rather than lament rising pump prices, why don’t you do something about it if you can? I’ll say it again — if you don’t own an oil company, buy one.

Bo Billeaud has served as president and chief investment officer of a Lafayette-based money management firm for the past 20 years.

To post a comment, please log into your IND account. If you do not have an account, click the "register" button to create one. Facebook comments can be used as an alternative to creating an account at theIND.com.

feed-image RSS Feed
Loading
Chart
ABiz Stock Watch
o Home Bancorp 22.09 ▼0.26 (-1.16%)
o Frank's International 22.72 ▼0.30 (-1.30%)
o IberiaBank Corp 65.82 ▼0.76 (-1.14%)
o LHC Group 21.45 ▼0.18 (-0.83%)
o MidSouth Bancorp 18.48 ▼0.24 (-1.28%)
o Petroquest Energy 6.63 ▼0.20 (-2.93%)
o PHI Inc. 38.10 0.00 (0.00%)
o Superior Energy 35.64 ▼0.25 (-0.70%)
o Stone Energy 40.13 ▼0.86 (-2.10%)
o Teche Holding 71.82 (%)
o Facebook Inc. 75.43 ▲0.45 (0.60%)
o Twitter Inc. 38.29 ▼0.42 (-1.08%)
o Gannett 33.34 ▼0.13 (-0.39%)
NYSE:HBCP

Home Bancorp

Company ID [NYSE:HBCP] Last trade:22.09 Trade time:11:52AM EDT Value change:▼0.26 (-1.16%)
NYSE:FI

Frank's International

Company ID [NYSE:FI] Last trade:22.72 Trade time:12:02PM EDT Value change:▼0.30 (-1.30%)
NYSE:IBKC

IberiaBank Corp

Company ID [NYSE:IBKC] Last trade:65.82 Trade time:11:53AM EDT Value change:▼0.76 (-1.14%)
NYSE:LHCG

LHC Group

Company ID [NYSE:LHCG] Last trade:21.45 Trade time:12:00PM EDT Value change:▼0.18 (-0.83%)
NYSE:MSL

MidSouth Bancorp

Company ID [NYSE:MSL] Last trade:18.48 Trade time:11:53AM EDT Value change:▼0.24 (-1.28%)
NYSE:PQ

Petroquest Energy

Company ID [NYSE:PQ] Last trade:6.63 Trade time:12:05PM EDT Value change:▼0.20 (-2.93%)
NYSE:PHII

PHI Inc.

Company ID [NYSE:PHII] Last trade:38.10 Trade time:2:53PM EDT Value change:0.00 (0.00%)
NYSE:SPN

Superior Energy

Company ID [NYSE:SPN] Last trade:35.64 Trade time:12:05PM EDT Value change:▼0.25 (-0.70%)
NYSE:SGY

Stone Energy

Company ID [NYSE:SGY] Last trade:40.13 Trade time:12:02PM EDT Value change:▼0.86 (-2.10%)
NYSE:TSH

Teche Holding

Company ID [NYSE:TSH] Last trade:71.82 Trade time:4:03PM EDT Value change: (%)
NYSE:FB

Facebook Inc.

Company ID [NYSE:FB] Last trade:75.43 Trade time:12:05PM EDT Value change:▲0.45 (0.60%)
NYSE:TWTR

Twitter Inc.

Company ID [NYSE:TWTR] Last trade:38.29 Trade time:12:05PM EDT Value change:▼0.42 (-1.08%)
NYSE:GCI

Gannett

Company ID [NYSE:GCI] Last trade:33.34 Trade time:12:05PM EDT Value change:▼0.13 (-0.39%)
Advertisement

Read the Flipping Paper!

Click Here for the Entire Print Version of
ABiz
 
Advertisement
Advertisement