News -> INDReporter WED, APR 7 7:58AM by Walter Pierce

‘City’ council members attack charter commish

Gentlemanly fireworks flew at Tuesday’s Lafayette City-Parish Council meeting as some members of the body representing majority city districts took aim at an introductory ordinance by council Chairman Jay Castille that would create an official charter commission to review and possibly amend the current Lafayette Home Rule Charter. The backdrop for the discussion is talk of repealing the charter and returning the parish to dual city and parish forms of government. And while the intro ordinance passed by a 5-3 vote (District 8 Councilman Keith Patin was absent), it did not advance without more than an hour of sometimes heated discussion. Typically introductory ordinances are passed without discussion as a matter of deference to the ordinance sponsor. Not Tuesday. Castille’s charter commission ordinance was pulled from the batch and pulled apart by the city men.

“I really do believe that creating a commission at this time would circumvent the purpose of the town hall meetings,” said District 4 Councilman Kenneth Boudreaux in an opening salvo, “and that is hearing from the people and truly finding out what they desire in the creation of a government and whether they want to remain in the current form of government or consider any alternative forms of government.”

Councilmen Don Bertrand (District 7) and Brandon Shelvin (District 3) also joined the fray, arguing against the formation of a charter commission until — at the very least — City-Parish President Joey Durel has completed his town hall meetings throughout the parish. Councilmen William Theriot (District 9) and Purvis Morrison (District 1), who represent Youngsville and Scott, respectively, reiterated their opposition to repealing the charter.

Morrison reminded the panel that there are not enough votes on the council to advance a deconsolidation ordinance to a parish-wide vote, precipitating a terse exchange with Bertrand, who recounted a recent experience at a town hall meeting outside the city of Lafayette: “There is one municipality in the parish of Lafayette that does not have autonomy, and that is the city of Lafayette,” Bertrand said.

“How many of you are in favor of keeping consolidation? All the hands go up,” he observed, referring to a question raised by Durel at that rural town hall. “Then you ask, ‘How many of you in the municipalities are willing to go whole hog on consolidation and join true consolidation and drop your local governments?’ And all the hands go down.”

“Is that not a clear message?” Morrison responded.

“It is a clear message,” Bertrand replied. “And that’s exactly what I’m trying to say that you’re not paying attention to. What you’re not paying attention to is there’s one municipality in the parish of Lafayette that does not have that autonomy, and that is the city of Lafayette, and that is what I’m also hearing at the town hall meetings.”

While maintaining his composure, Castille was clearly put off by the discussion. “I did make the comment when I became chair,” he said, “that this would be an exciting year. It’s right on track.”


Walter Pierce
About the author:


Comments (8)add
...
written by Southside , April 07, 2010 - 09:29 pm
We need a commission to tell us that the present form of government isn't working? We need a commision to decide the fate of the city of lafayette? How about just putting it to a public vote? Whats so hard to understand about this situation? I understand its all about the towns losing their voice in the city of lafayette matters. The problem is, we don't WANT their input, or drain of monies anymore. We, the citizens of lafayette are tired of funding the towns projects, tired of the towns having a say-so in lafayette matters while not having a vote in their matters. I don't fault the towns mayors. They are looking out for their towns. I DO fault the previous and present city presidents for not looking out for their own city. Get rid of the whole bunch, starting with Castille. Since the city of lafayette seats the Parish government, a representative of the city should be the head parish councilman.
...
written by EXISTENTIALIST MAN , April 08, 2010 - 01:16 am
The city of Lafayette, should have a leader in the form of a Mayor, a city council, a city police chief, a city clerk,
a city animal control officer,etc............

The Parish of Lafayette, should have a leader in the form of a Parish Commissioner, the number of parish councilmen from each outlying municipality to be determined by the number of the municipality's voter population , a parish law enforcement administrator, a parish clerk, a parish animal control officer, etc......


I guarantee you with the City monitoring, and administering city business ..........
The Parish monitoring, and administering parish business...........

Ay , and never the twain shall meet, like separating Church and State, you could count on this, "you would never see one, "Deviling into the affairs of the other, ( Yes, thats a word ! )also very fitting in our current administration, and this would certainly eliminate the sticky hands disease which is a common ailment with our politicians...,. Imagine this, the City's Fox guarding the Parish hen house, and the Parish Fox guarding the City's hen house............
* Viola, the end of graft and corruption, all the scam artists, con-artists and shifty land grabbers, move to greener pastures, we win the prize for the most, RAT-FREE CITY/PARISH IN LOUISIANA... FINALLY ! WE WOULD BE FIRST IN SOMETHING, WE WOULD'NT HAVE TO HANG OUR HEAD OVER..........
AY, CAN YOU DIG IT, " NO CORRUPTION ! AY WE'D GET MORE FANFARE THAN JOEY AND LUS, EH ?
...
written by Buckley , April 08, 2010 - 05:19 pm
If you live in Lafayette,and you have a municipality related problem, you can petition your council person. Unfortunately, if said problem does not garner empathy with parish council folks ( how to dispose of pig manure, say)your council person will probably not be able to help you. If you labor under the theory that things like art funding enhances the quality off life and therefore enhances the attractiveness of the city which in turns brings money into the community,well,I don't think your councilman has even a slight chance of helping you.Because even though he is your representitive, he operates in an inherently flawed system (City/Parish Consolidated Government)in which he has no ability to manuver i.e. there is no real means for you to be represented.Early Americans encountered this.They called it TAXATION WITHOUT REPRESENTATION and really, they got worked up into a snit about the thing. At least Jay Castille wants to study the situation for a while (2016, to be exact).And you know, that's nice and all, but given his limited capabilities, I don't think that he will ever arrive at the realization that under any other circumstances, this would be considered taking away the public's essential right to vote.Folks, we have a right to vote,damn the consequences, unintended or otherwise.Put it to a vote. I don't mean to be unkind, but what's the point of a commission when their is not enough collective gray matter to add two and two.Our fate as a community is in the hands of a bunch of unqualified boobs who would have voted against the Rural Electrification Act because it might upset the chickens.C'mon on people, Lafayette's fate and future as a world class city cannot be left up to lot of "rural sensibility". It's high time we took our town back.
...
written by EXISTENTIALIST MAN , April 08, 2010 - 06:40 pm
BUCKLEY AND SOLUTIONS *WISEMEN SPEAK BECAUSE THEY HAVE SOMETHING TO SAY, FOOLS SPEAK BECAUSE THEY HAVE TO SAY SOMETHING !
FOR EVERY PROBLEM, THERE EXIST A SOLUTION, AND TO OVERCOME ANY PROBLEM, YOU MUST BEGIN WITH THE ORIGIN OF THE PROBLEM,
KILL THE HEAD AND THE BODY DIES......
...
written by EXISTENTIALIST MAN , April 08, 2010 - 06:55 pm
"""DUBIUM SUPIENTIAE UNITIUM, DOUBT IS THE ORIGIN OF WISDOM", YOU ALL HAVE SOMETHING TO SAY, YOU SEE A WRONG AND YOU WANT IT RIGHTED, BUT WANTING SOMETHING IS LIKE WISHING SOMETHING,
IF YOU WANT SOMETHING, YOU HAVE TO GO AFTER WHAT YOU WANT, YOURSELF.................
...
written by NORTHSIDIAN MAN , April 08, 2010 - 07:03 pm
YA'LL ALL HAVE SOMETHING TO BEEF ABOUT..... WHY DON'T YA'LL FORM A COALITION ( THE GOVERNMENT FINANCES SUCH GROUPS, AKA JESSE JACKSON COALITION )AND YOU CAN USE GOVERNMENT AID TO CLEAN UP THE GOVERNMENT...CALL YOSELF THE "3 CRAP-STIRRERS!
AY LOOK WHEN YOU GET THEM DOWN,""" KICK EM TIL THEIR NOSES BLEED...........
...
written by Buckley , April 08, 2010 - 07:51 pm
well Existentialist Man, I don't quite follow you. Voting, it seems to me, is a solution.No? I mean, It's a little hard to respond to something so cryptic.Wise men?Fools? What's that about? You suggesting someone is being a fool?Nothing like a little dollop of Latin to give it just that special specious spin.
cave quid dicis,quando,et cui
...
written by Buckley , April 08, 2010 - 10:26 pm
...and you don't know what it is, do you Mr.Jones...(existentialist man)
You must be logged in to post a comment. Log in using your Facebook account or register if you do not have an account yet.

busy 
LA LA Land
Advertisement
Most Read
Advertisement
Advertisement
in case you missed it